Netflix has been steadily reshaping expectations for what a live-action anime adaptation can be, more so with its hit fantasy series that makes even Naruto look small. The success of this fantasy show is even more admirable, given how many streaming platforms, production companies, and networks have failed to do justice to their anime source material.
Among Netflix’s best live-action anime series is One Piece, a fantasy show that has surprisingly done the impossible by creating a story that not only feels vast but is an accurate representation of its source material. One Piece does a splendid job of bringing Eiichiro Oda’s manga to life with its intricate world and larger-than-life characters.
Part of why One Piece feels endless is how the adaptation treats exploration. In the series, travel and adventure are the backbone of its premise because it’s a narrative event in itself. Where many anime adaptations and even their source materials tend to centralize action around villages, kingdoms, or recurring strongholds, One Piece does the opposite. The Netflix series constantly expands outward, thus contributing to the vastness of its world.
The Scale Of Netflix’s One Piece Adaptation Makes Naruto’s World Look Small In Comparison
Netflix’s version of One Piece naturally creates the impression of a far larger and more expansive universe than Naruto. At the center of this world is the Grand Line, an unstable ocean route that defies normal geography. Unlike typical fantasy maps, where continents are the primary focus, One Piece treats the ocean and its surrounding lands a bit differently. Every island that the Straw Hats land on, whether it’s Shells Town or Orange Town, has its own distinct style, characters, and culture, which in turn creates a universe that seems endless.
Undoubtedly, great care has been taken to bring the One Piece live-action series to life with every scene, fight, and location feeling grander than the last. While One Piece’s story is continuous, each episode is shot like a mini-movie due to its incredible worldbuilding. That’s not to take anything away from Naruto. After all, the anime’s world is also pretty expansive. The difference between the two shows is that Naruto is more localized because most of the anime occurs in Konoha Village, whereas the heroes in One Piece essentially travel around the world.
There’s also something quite dreamlike about One Piece. The islands, ocean, and strange ensemble of characters ranging from Buggy the Clown to Dracule Mihawk feel out of this world. Naruto, in comparison, tends to feel small because it is, in a way, a straightforward hero story. If a live-action Naruto series were to be created, it’s doubtful that it could be as grand as the Netflix fantasy show.
Naruto’s World Feels Smaller Than One Piece, Despite Being Technically Bigger
On paper, Naruto has a much bigger and more complex world than Netflix’s One Piece. This is because the sprawling anime has several nations, different clans, and a rich history. In fact, Naruto even included the concept of parallel universes when it featured the Kamui dimension and spiritual realms like the Pure Land. Despite this, One Piece still feels like the more enormous universe.
One Piece Season 3’s Confirmed Release Solves The Netflix Adaptation’s Only Real Flaw
Because Netflix has confirmed that One Piece season 3 will be released in 2027, this plan also solves a problem inherent in this adaptation.
Netflix’s One Piece does not have alternate universes, at least for now. Everything from the Grand Line to the Fish-Man Island exists within the same universe, timeline, and reality. Even the strangest places that feel like they are outside the show’s world are still part of the same universe in the live-action series. Given that Luffy and his crew are always on the move and are constantly discovering new worlds, it gives the illusion that One Piece is on a bigger scale than Naruto.
One Piece isn’t likely to introduce parallel universes in the future, seeing as the creator of the story, Eiichiro Oda, has mostly centralized his premise to one reality. It actually wouldn’t make sense if the live-action show decided to go in that direction, as its story is already massive. However, One Piece is also a pretty strange series, so there’s no way of knowing for sure if the live-action TV show will stick to one dimension.
- Release Date
-
August 31, 2023
- Network
-
Netflix
- Showrunner
-
Matt Owens, Steven Maeda, Joe Tracz
- Directors
-
Tim Southam, Marc Jobst, Josef Kubota Wladyka
- Writers
-
Tiffany Greshler, Diego Gutierrez, Allison Weintraub, Lindsay Gelfand
-
Iñaki Godoy
Monkey D. Luffy
-
