It’s fitting that Prime Video’s upcoming Stranger Things replacement is based on an iconic Stephen King novel because the iconic Netflix show from the Duffer Brothers is heavily influenced by the “King of Horror.” When Stranger Things premiered in 2016, its story of a group of outcast teens fighting monsters from a scary alternate universe in their hometown of Hawkins, Indiana, instantly resonated with audiences.
After five seasons released across almost a decade, Stranger Things‘ series finale aired at the end of 2025. Throughout its run, the show became the biggest in Netflix’s history, with Stranger Things breaking streaming records no other series has yet to top.
As the Duffer Brothers were becoming household names, another creator was also making a name for himself in Netflix’s horror landscape: Mike Flanagan. After the massive success of Flanagan’s Netflix horror miniseries, The Haunting of Hill House, in 2018, he signed a multi-year exclusivity deal with the streamer, during which time he made The Haunting of Bly Manor (2020), Midnight Mass (2021), The Midnight Club (2022), and The Fall of the House of Usher (2023).
Now that his contract with Netflix has expired, Flanagan has hopped over to Amazon MGM Studios, with whom he has signed a similar multi-year exclusivity contract. His inaugural series under this new partnership will be none other than Carrie, an eight-episode miniseries adaptation of King’s 1974 debut novel about the titular bullied teenager from an abusive religious household who discovers she has telekinetic powers and seeks bloody revenge on her tormentors on prom night.
Though there have been three feature-length Carrie films, this is the first time King’s novel is receiving a television series adaptation. Set to premiere in October 2026, Flanagan’s Carrie may very well fill the TV horror void left by Stranger Things.
Prime Video’s Carrie Series Shares Key Themes In Common With Stranger Things
In many ways, Stranger Things is very much cut from the same cloth as Carrie, even if it’s much more PG-rated. This is perhaps best seen in the show’s answer to the Stephen King antiheroine: Eleven.
Like Carrie White, Eleven not only possesses incredibly strong telekinetic powers, but she was also raised in a heavily controlled, isolated environment. Whereas Carrie was raised under the thumb of a tyrannical zealot of a mother, Eleven grew up in a lab in which scientists performed forcible experiments on her to learn about and exploit her paranormal abilities.
Unlike previous adaptations, Flanagan’s Carrie will explore the origins of the protagonist’s powers. In an interview with EW, Flanagan said, “Stephen King also talks about the ‘TK gene’ [for telekinesis] and the science behind Carrie’s abilities. Something that the [Brian] De Palma adaptation ignored was Carrie’s place in the larger universe, that she’s part of a sorority of very gifted women and just doesn’t know it. The book absolutely points at that, but that was something we could pick up and run with.“
This is yet another thing the Prime Video series has in common with Stranger Things, which explored the backstory of Eleven’s abilities in great detail. As superpowered outsiders, Eleven and Carrie are opposite sides of the same coin — Eleven used her powers for good, and Carrie, well, did not. It’ll be fascinating to see how that plays out in Flanagan’s series.
Expect Prime Video’s Carrie To Be Very Different From The Iconic ’70s Movie
As fantastic as Brian De Palma’s Carrie, which made stars out of then-unknowns Sissy Spacek and John Travolta, is, Flanagan has made it clear that his Prime Video show will not be a remake of the 1976 movie. For starters, the story won’t take place in the 1970s, but in the present day.
Another change from the Carrie book and the De Palma movie is the role of Carrie’s father. In both previous works, Ralph White wasn’t in the picture, but in Flanagan’s series, his sudden death is the inciting incident, as it results in Carrie (Summer H. Howell) being forced to attend public school for the first time. She immediately becomes embroiled in a viral bullying scandal, and things only get worse for the telekinetic teen from there.
Flanagan told EW, “The themes that Steve was talking about half a century ago of kindness versus cruelty, of empathy and bullying, and violence at school have become even more relevant today than he could have contemplated because of our relationship to technology and the degree to which violence encroaches on our high schoolers, especially in the United States… So that meant we had an opportunity to tell a story about a modern teenage experience that could use the seeds of these characters King created 50 years ago, but express them completely differently.”
However, perhaps most importantly, Flanagan has teased that the climactic prom scene — in which Carrie’s bullies cruelly dump a bucket of pig’s blood on her after she is crowned prom queen, prompting her murderous rampage — will be unlike anything seen before. “We’re getting there a completely different way and the events of that prom are going to be completely different… That’s a wonderfully delicious and irresistible opportunity for someone who loves adapting things.“
On the one hand, this is a bit worrisome to Carrie fans who live for the ultimate revenge scene. However, we’ve seen it three times already in previous adaptations. Plus, Flanagan has more than proved his street cred as the ultimate small-screen horror storyteller. While time will tell if his Prime Video series will reach the icon status of Stranger Things, it’s all but guaranteed to be a bloody good watch.
Source: EW
-
-
Summer H. Howell
Carrie White
-
Matthew Lillard
Principal Grayle
-
Samantha Sloyan
Margaret White